Skip to main content

Same old song

In North Wales this week, we have witnessed yet more acts of corporate arrogance which continue to anger and infuriate the local population. As I observe events unfold, one thing strikes me in particular. As angry as people undoubtedly are, they don't quite seem to know what to do about it. But that is not their fault.

This week alone, three decisions in particular have dominated our local news. The week began with news that the plight of a 90 year old lady had finally been addressed by the local council. But let us not get too carried away with ourselves. It is only the plight of one elderly lady which has been addressed. The decision of the local council to close the three local council-run care homes was met with a good degree of opposition.

In the first instance, a young lady from one of the towns affected achieved a petition with over 5,000 signatures. Given the modest size of the local population, that was a considerable achievement. The response of the council to this amazing feat of human engagement was to largely ignore it. At best, that is plain ignorant. At worst, it is arrogance of the very worst type. The 90 year old lady in question became a cause celebre on account of her having raised many thousands for her local care home throughout her life before being told there would be no place for her even with failing eyesight. In the end, it was more to do with the intervention of local politicians than the petition of 5,000 people which reversed the council decision. But I reiterate, this was just a victory for one person, however laudable that was. At the time of writing, there is nothing to suggest that the planned care home closures won't be enacted as planned by the local council. This gets to the heart of the matter. Unchallenged, they will surely succeed. But that challenge needs to come from sources more direct than social media. Public demonstrations and the interventions of elected political representatives will effect the greatest outcomes. A public meeting has been called for February 26th in the town of Corwen but I sincerely hope that the numbers on social media can translate to real life. My recent experiences make me doubtful but I will gladly be proved wrong.

Not two weeks after the Welsh Assembly Government opposed the intention of the local council to close a Church of England primary school, the local Council wasted no time in restating their aim to close it. Whether the small band of hardy parents and governors can once more beat the corporate machine remains to be seen but I wish them luck. The point here is rather sobering. My local council has an idea to execute a decision and not even the intervention of the national government will assuage them. That is a chilling indictment of the democracy which we are now left with.  

Just yesterday, the local health board announced that maternity services would soon be dropped at one of our district general hospitals. The decision was greeted with a public outcry and once again, local people flocked to social media to register their opposition. All well and good. The real acid test though is translating those sentiments on social media in to actions in real life. Irrespective of my own opinion on this decision, I am far more interested to see if local people will put their money where there mouth is and vote with their feet. If they do, they will make strides toward dispelling the myth that social media has become the domain of the whinger who lacks the conviction to convert his or her thoughts in to actions.

Of course, it is also instructive to note that all three decisions which have caused so much public opprobrium, have been made by unelected people without the input of local tax-payers. Maybe the time has come to question the suitability of such a system. But will people take the next big leap and play their part in making that happen?

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Tony Blair - Not fade away?

Notwithstanding the current involvement of Gordon Brown in the current political debate surrounding the Scottish Referendum vote, it is customary for former prime ministers of the United Kingdom to fade gracefully in to the background and make way for the new breed. Margaret Thatcher, Edward Heath, Jim Callaghan and Harold Wilson all achieved this simple task without too much fuss. John Major occasionally interjects with an opinion but usually long after the boat has left the harbour. Tony Blair alone seems quite oblivious to this unspoken rule of British political life. An eleventh year leading the country was quite enough for Lady Thatcher when her party dispensed with her services. It seems that Tony Blair can't get enough of power. He is beginning to come across as one of those computer viruses which just won't go away once it has been granted access. We begin to rue the day we ever clicked the "yes" button. The virus invades our entire system and seems ubiquito...

Are you being served?

Denbighshire County Council (DCC) have just published their Resident's Survey Report. And an interesting read it is too. But before scrutinising the content of that Report, it is interesting to note that the Local Government Data Unit has just announced that DCC was one of the top 5 performing Councils in Wales during 2015/16. But sadly, the Resident's Survey Report was not used to come to this conclusion. If it had been used, it would be difficult to believe that DCC is one of the best performing councils in Wales - unless the others are even worse. Although I'm not sure if DCC are legally required to conduct a Resident's Survey, I would have thought it to be an obvious thing to do. To quote the Local Government Authority, "Understanding the resident's views is a key element of assessing the effectiveness of an authority, alongside cost and performance information. Furthermore, understanding resident satisfaction and being able to make informed comparison...

Breaking the cycle

I have always been drawn to a good analogy. Recently, a very simple analogy was related to me which can be adapted to just about every walk of life. The analogy tells of a man standing on the banks of a river fishing dead bodies out as they float downstream. Another man comes along and instead walks upstream to try and find where they are coming from. Like all truly great analogies it is beautiful in its simplicity and easy to follow. I applied it in several contexts as I am sure you will already have done. In their wisdom (and if I was inclined to a mere slither of cynicism), the Welsh Government have once again sought to emulate their Scottish cousins by proposing a minimum pricing on alcohol. They claim that a minimum price of 50p per unit of alcohol might save the Welsh economy £1 billion annually. That is quite a claim. This is apparently based on research assessing crime, illness and workplace absence over the last 20 years. So why not just introduce this measure (no pun intend...